Koch's postulates – finding the cause of a leaf-spot disease of a crop plant

BiologyHealth & DiseaseAges 15–16Virtual lab

Use with my class

A schematic of Koch's four postulates applied to a made-up leaf-spot of bean plants, with three unnamed suspects: bacterium X, bacterium Y and agent Z. Examine samples from diseased and healthy plants, spread a sample on a plate and pick a colony to get a pure culture, apply the pure culture to healthy plants beside controls sprayed with sterile water, and re-isolate from the new spots. Each postulate is recorded with its observation and whether it is met.

Lesson: Koch's postulates and the causes of infectious disease

What it shows

Koch's postulates are four tests for deciding whether a particular microbe causes a disease. The microbe must be found in every diseased host but not in healthy ones, be grown in pure culture, cause the same disease when given to a healthy host, and be isolated again from that host. Here the host is a crop plant with a leaf-spot and three suspects are tested in turn. One meets all four postulates, one also lives on healthy leaves, and one cannot be grown outside living cells, which shows a limit of the postulates.

How to use

Choose a Suspect, then work through the four postulates. Press Examine a sick and a healthy plant, Spread a sick-leaf sample on a plate (tap a colony, then Grow a pure culture from this colony), Apply the culture and wait 10 days, and Sample a new spot and grow it. Record and go on adds each observation to the table. Plants per group sets the size of the two groups.

Parameters you can change

  • Suspect Bacterium X, Bacterium Y, Agent Z
  • Plants per group (postulate 3) 5–20

Questions to explore

  1. Why is it not enough to find a microbe in every diseased plant to show that it causes the disease?
  2. Why must the microbe be grown in pure culture before it is given to healthy plants?
  3. Why can Koch's postulates not be fully applied to agent Z or to viruses?