Limiting Reactant and Percentage Yield – Stoichiometry with Particles

ChemistryReactions & RedoxAges 15–16

Use with my class

Choose a reaction (2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O, N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃, CH₄ + 2O₂ → CO₂ + 2H₂O, Fe + S → FeS), set the amounts of the two reactants as particles, moles or grams, and let it react: the particle picture shows which reactant runs out, and the mole–mass table gives the excess, the theoretical yield and the percentage yield. An Atom economy tab compares two routes to ethanol, chloroethane and ethanoic acid by atom economy, percentage yield (one route measured by titration), E-factor, feedstock, energy and GHS hazards.

Lesson: Reacting quantities: limiting reactant, excess reactant and percentage yield

What it shows

Reactants combine in the mole ratio of the balanced equation: dividing the amount of each reactant by its coefficient shows the limiting reactant, which decides the theoretical yield, and the actual yield gives the percentage yield. Atom economy asks a different question: what fraction of the reactants’ mass can end up in the wanted product at all? Addition reactions reach 100%, while substitution, fermentation and oxidation lose atoms to a by-product. Green chemistry weighs both numbers together with waste (E-factor), renewable feedstocks, energy use and hazards. The model assumes each reaction goes to completion; yields in the Atom economy tab are typical values.

How to use

On Limiting reactant, pick a Reaction and a Unit, set the two starting amounts and press React; type the actual yield to see the percentage yield. On Atom economy, choose a Product and a Route, press Carry out, then calculate the atom economy and the percentage yield (from the mass or the titres) and press Check. Each checked route goes into the table, so compare the two routes for each product.

Parameters you can change

  • Reaction 2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O, N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃, CH₄ + 2O₂ → CO₂ + 2H₂O, Fe + S → FeS
  • Unit of amount Particles, Moles, Mass (g)
  • Amount of the first reactant (in the chosen unit) 0–100
  • Amount of the second reactant (in the chosen unit) 0–100
  • Actual yield of product (in the chosen unit, 0 = not entered) 0–1000
  • View Limiting reactant, Atom economy
  • Product (atom economy) Ethanol, Chloroethane, Ethanoic acid
  • Route first route (fermentation, substitution or oxidation), second route (hydration, addition or carbonylation)

Questions to explore

  1. Mixing 4 g of H₂ with 16 g of O₂, why does O₂ run out first even though there is less H₂ by mass?
  2. For N₂ + 3H₂ → 2NH₃, how many moles of H₂ react exactly with 2 mol of N₂?
  3. Why is the actual yield of ammonia in industry far below the theoretical yield?
  4. Why does making ethanol by fermentation have a lower atom economy than the hydration of ethene?
  5. Can a route with 100% atom economy still have a low percentage yield? Give a reason.

Teaching ideas

All guides