Biomaterials for implants – choosing metals, ceramics, polymers and hydrogels

ChemistryApplied & Practical ChemistryAges 17–18

Use with my class

A design challenge: choose the material for a hip joint stem, a dental implant, a bone screw, an artery stent and a wound dressing from titanium alloy, 316L stainless steel, alumina, hydroxyapatite ceramic, PLA (a biodegradable polymer) and hydrogel. Readouts compare the Young modulus with bone (about 10–30 GPa), strength, elongation, biocompatibility, corrosion in simulated body fluid (0.9% NaCl at 37 °C) and degradation time, and a soak test weighs samples before and after soaking. Every choice and soak goes into a table.

Lesson: Biomaterials: choosing a material from its properties

What it shows

An implant must do its mechanical job and live peacefully in the body. Metals such as titanium alloy and stainless steel are strong, ceramics such as alumina and hydroxyapatite are hard but brittle, PLA is a polymer that the body slowly absorbs, and hydrogels are soft and full of water. You compare their stiffness with bone, their strength and stretch, how they behave in body fluid and how long they last, then pick the best material for each use and explain why. Property values are typical published ranges; the soak-test curves are illustrative.

How to use

On Choose a material, pick a Use and read what it needs, then pick a Material and compare its readouts and the two charts. Press Choose for this use to record it and see the verdict. On Soak test, choose a material and Soak time, press Start soak, and calculate the percentage mass change in the task box. Find the best material for all five uses.

Parameters you can change

  • Screen Choose a material, Soak test
  • Use Hip joint stem, Dental implant, Bone screw, Artery stent, Wound dressing
  • Material Titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V), Stainless steel 316L, Alumina ceramic (Al₂O₃), Hydroxyapatite ceramic, PLA (polylactic acid), Hydrogel
  • Soak time 1–52 weeks

Questions to explore

  1. Why can a stem that is much stiffer than bone make the femur around it thinner over the years?
  2. Why is a biodegradable PLA screw useful for a small fracture but not for a hip joint?
  3. What happened to the mass of PLA in your soak tests as the soaking time grew?