Boat crossing a river – relative velocity

PhysicsKinematicsAges 15–16

Use with my class

A boat moves at speed v₁₂ relative to the water on a river flowing at v₂₃. Change the heading angle θ with the slider or by dragging on the river to see the velocity triangle v₁₃ = v₁₂ + v₂₃, the path, the crossing time and the drift; a graph shows how time and drift depend on θ. One button works out the upstream angle needed to land directly opposite. A View menu adds the same crossing seen side by side from the bank and from the drifting water, and a ball dropped in a moving train, which falls straight down for a passenger and along a parabola seen from the platform.

Lesson: Relative velocity – adding velocities

What it shows

A boat on a river combines two velocities: its velocity relative to the water, v₁₂, and the water's velocity relative to the bank, v₂₃. Relative to the bank it moves at v₁₃ = v₁₂ + v₂₃, so the crossing time is t = d/(v₁₂ cos θ) and the drift is x = (v₂₃ − v₁₂ sin θ)·t. The two-frames view shows the same crossing from the bank and from the drifting water, where the boat simply follows its bow. The train view drops a ball in a moving train: straight down for a passenger, a parabola from the platform. Wind, waves and air resistance are ignored.

How to use

Set Boat speed relative to water, Current speed and River width, then press Start. Use Heading angle θ, or drag on the river, to aim the bow; Head straight across gives the fastest crossing and Land opposite reaches B. Switch Current to Slow at banks, fast in middle for a curved path. Under View, pick Two frames: bank and water or Train and platform, then press Record position to fill the table.

Parameters you can change

  • River width 20–300 m
  • Boat speed relative to water 0.5–8 m/s
  • Current speed 0–6 m/s
  • Heading angle (positive: upstream) -85–85 °
  • Current Uniform across the river, Slow at banks, fast in middle
  • View River crossing, Two frames: bank and water, Train and platform
  • Train speed relative to the platform 0–20 m/s
  • Drop height above the train floor 0.5–2.5 m

Questions to explore

  1. Why does a faster current not change the crossing time when the boat heads straight across?
  2. How must the boat be aimed to land directly opposite, and what happens to the crossing time?
  3. If the current is faster than the boat, can it ever land directly opposite its starting point?
  4. Why does a ball dropped in a moving train land below the hand, although it moves forward seen from the platform?