Rate of reaction by turbidity and colour – disappearing cross and crystal violet

ChemistryKinetics & EquilibriumAges 15–16Virtual lab

Use with my class

A virtual lab with two ways to measure a rate of reaction without collecting gas. Disappearing cross: Na₂S₂O₃ + HCl forms sulfur that slowly clouds the solution; students time how long the cross takes to vanish, calculate 1/t and plot it against concentration and temperature. Colorimeter: crystal violet fades in excess NaOH; students compare the A, ln A and 1/A graphs to show the reaction is first order in the dye and find the rate constant k. Analysis screens add initial-rates experiments that change one reactant at a time to find the orders, the rate equation and the rate-determining step, and an Arrhenius plot of ln k against 1/T that gives Eₐ and A. Iodine clock: time the sudden blue-black colour of H₂O₂ + KI with thiosulfate and starch, or of KIO₃ + Na₂SO₃, and plot 1/t against [I⁻] or [IO₃⁻] and against temperature to find the order and Eₐ. The Rate laws screen compares six reactions, from ammonia on hot platinum to ester hydrolysis and the inversion of sucrose, using [A]–t, ln[A]–t and 1/[A]–t graphs and half-lives to tell zero order from first order.

Lesson: Rates of reaction – measuring rate, effect of concentration and temperature, rate constant

What it shows

Two classic ways to follow a reaction without collecting gas. In the disappearing-cross method, thiosulfate and acid form colloidal sulfur until a cross under the flask vanishes; every run stops at the same amount of sulfur, so 1/t measures the average rate. In the colorimeter method, crystal violet fades in excess hydroxide, and only the ln A against time graph is straight, showing first order. The analysis screens deduce orders from initial rates, changing one concentration at a time, test proposed rate-determining steps against the rate equation, and use an Arrhenius plot of ln k against 1/T to find Eₐ and A. The iodine clock times how long a fixed small amount of thiosulfate or sulfite lasts before free iodine turns starch blue-black. The Rate laws screen follows one reactant until three quarters has reacted: for zero order [A] falls in a straight line and t½ = [A]₀/2k grows with [A]₀, while for first order ln [A] is straight and t½ = ln 2/k stays constant.

How to use

Choose the Method. For the disappearing cross, set Na₂S₂O₃ 0.15 M and Temperature, press Add HCl, start timer, then Cross gone – stop. For the colorimeter, set [OH⁻], press Start measuring and compare A – t, ln A – t and 1/A – t. On Initial rates, choose the Reaction and concentrations, press Measure initial rate, then tap a mechanism. On Arrhenius plot, press Measure k at several temperatures. For the Iodine clock, choose the Clock reaction and the Volume, press Add H₂O₂, start timer (or Add Na₂SO₃) and stop at the blue-black colour. On Rate laws, choose the Reaction and Initial concentration, press Start run, and compare the three graphs and the half-lives.

Parameters you can change

  • Measurement method Disappearing cross (Na₂S₂O₃ + HCl), Colorimeter (crystal violet + NaOH), Iodine clock (H₂O₂ + KI or KIO₃ + Na₂SO₃)
  • Volume of 0.15 M Na₂S₂O₃ (made up to 50 mL with water) 10–50 mL
  • Temperature 10–50 °C
  • OH⁻ concentration (NaOH, colorimeter) 0.01–0.1 M
  • Screen Experiment (disappearing cross, colorimeter), Initial rates and rate equation, Arrhenius plot (ln k against 1/T), Rate laws: zero and first order
  • Reaction (analysis screens) Iodination of propanone (acid catalyst), Hydrolysis of 2-bromo-2-methylpropane, Hydrolysis of bromoethane, Bromate and bromide in acid
  • Iodine clock reaction H₂O₂ + KI with thiosulfate and starch, KIO₃ + Na₂SO₃ with starch (Landolt)
  • Volume of KI 0.10 M or KIO₃ 0.020 M (made up to 25 mL with water) 5–25 mL
  • Reaction (Rate laws screen) Decomposition of NH₃ on hot platinum, Iodination of propanone (I₂ followed), Decomposition of N₂O₅ in CCl₄, Crystal violet in NaOH, Acid hydrolysis of ethyl ethanoate, Inversion of sucrose (acid)

Questions to explore

  1. Why can 1/t be used as a measure of the rate in the disappearing-cross experiment?
  2. How does the time for the cross to disappear change when the temperature rises by 10 °C?
  3. Why does a straight ln A against time graph show that the reaction is first order in crystal violet?

Teaching ideas

All guides